On January 9, 2025, the world paused to honor the life and legacy of former President Jimmy Carter. Held at the majestic National Cathedral in Washington, D.C., the funeral drew global attention as dignitaries, citizens, and admirers reflected on Carter’s extraordinary century-long life. While the occasion was marked by solemnity and reverence, one moment in particular stirred both admiration and controversy: a surprise musical tribute by country music icons Garth Brooks and Trisha Yearwood.
The duo, longtime friends and collaborators of the late president, performed John Lennon’s iconic “Imagine”—a song Carter personally cherished. Their unexpected choice instantly became a subject of discussion, sparking varied reactions from attendees and viewers alike.
A Song That Divided the Audience
“Imagine” is widely regarded as a call for global peace, unity, and shared humanity. However, its message—particularly its opening lyrics, “Imagine there’s no heaven”—was met with mixed reception given the explicitly Christian setting of the National Cathedral. For some, the performance struck a jarring chord, seemingly at odds with Carter’s devout faith and the religious context of the service.
While many commended the heartfelt delivery and saw it as a fitting tribute to Carter’s lifelong work for peace and human rights, others voiced discomfort over the philosophical tone of the song. Social media quickly lit up with commentary, ranging from thoughtful praise to sharp criticism, with some even questioning whether the performance unintentionally undermined the spiritual foundation of the memorial.
The Personal Connection Behind the Choice
To better understand the choice of “Imagine,” one must consider the deeply personal bond shared between Carter and the performers. Over the years, Brooks and Yearwood worked closely with Carter on humanitarian efforts, most notably through Habitat for Humanity. Their relationship extended beyond public service into friendship, built on mutual respect and shared ideals.
Carter himself had long expressed admiration for “Imagine,” seeing it as a symbol of peace transcending national and cultural boundaries. He reportedly referenced the song on several occasions, even during visits to countries like Cuba, where its message resonated strongly. For Brooks and Yearwood, honoring Carter with a song he held dear was a sincere gesture of remembrance—albeit one that stirred debate.
A Performance Met With Both Respect and Reflection
Despite the polarized reactions, the performance was not without merit in capturing the essence of Carter’s values. Known for his global humanitarianism and efforts toward diplomacy, Carter frequently embraced messages that championed empathy, dialogue, and a vision for a more unified world. In this light, “Imagine” could be interpreted as a heartfelt salute to the ideals he spent his life promoting.
Still, the context of the performance—within the walls of a Christian cathedral—inevitably sparked deeper reflection about how music and message interact with faith-based traditions. Some critics viewed the choice as culturally insensitive, while others defended it as an act of artistic and emotional honesty, rooted in a genuine desire to honor Carter’s memory.
Legacy, Love, and the Continuing Tribute
As Brooks and Yearwood continue their philanthropic work, their tribute remains a memorable moment in an already historic farewell. Their decision, while divisive, served as a testament to Carter’s unique and complex legacy—a man of faith who also embraced a broader vision of peace, inclusion, and humanity.
Following the service, both artists shared personal reflections and tributes via social media, thanking Carter for his guidance, friendship, and lifelong example. Their performance, ultimately, was a tribute rooted in love and shared ideals—an attempt to reflect the man Carter was and the values he championed.
In remembering Jimmy Carter, perhaps the most meaningful tribute is to continue the work he began—to uplift others, bridge divides, and imagine, just as he did, a better world.
