At first, I thought it was just cute.
Sunny and Beans had never been close—barely tolerated each other at my old place—but ever since I moved into this new apartment, they’d been inseparable. Curling up like puzzle pieces on the couch, always in the exact same position, like it was rehearsed.
I joked that maybe the new energy was good for them. Or maybe it was the sunlight in the living room. Whatever it was, I wasn’t questioning peace between cats.
But then… the pattern started.
Every morning, I’d wake up and find them exactly like this—facing each other, paws touching, tails curved like parentheses.
Always on the same spot.
Always on that worn-out corner cushion.
I didn’t think much of it at first. It was cute, like they had made some kind of unspoken agreement, a little ritual that seemed too perfect to be random. It was almost as if they had synchronized their routines overnight. But after a while, I started to feel… uneasy.
Sunny, the older one with the golden fur, was always the one who kept her distance. She was independent, aloof, only coming around when she felt like it. Beans, the younger one with his mischievous gray coat, used to follow her around, hoping for some attention, but she usually shrugged him off. So seeing them snuggled together so often—it didn’t sit right with me. Cats don’t just change their behavior like that, right? It seemed… unnatural.
One morning, as I walked into the living room, I noticed something I hadn’t seen before. There was a faint crease in the fabric of the couch, something tucked under the cushion where they always slept. I reached down, pulling it out, expecting maybe a toy or a cat hairball.
Instead, it was a photo. A small, slightly faded Polaroid, taped under the cushion, almost as if it had been hidden there on purpose.
The photo showed two cats—exactly like Sunny and Beans—sleeping in the same position. But the strange thing wasn’t the image. It was the timestamp on the bottom of the photo: October 2015.
I froze. That was over a year before I even moved into this apartment. I stared at it, confused. Who had taken this photo, and why was it under my couch cushion? Why was it there at all?
I rushed to the cats. Sunny was lounging on the windowsill, gazing out at the birds outside. Beans, as usual, was curled up in the exact spot on the couch where the photo had been. I examined him more closely. He seemed completely unaware of what was going on, looking up at me with those big, innocent eyes, his tail flicking lazily.
I couldn’t shake the eerie feeling, so I decided to get to the bottom of it. That night, after I fed them, I sat down on the couch and tried to think back to when I first moved in. The apartment complex had been relatively quiet, the kind of place where you could go weeks without seeing your neighbors. But there was one thing that stuck out to me: the landlord had been… odd. Always hovering around when I was moving in, acting like he had something to hide.
I remembered the strange conversation we’d had when I signed the lease. He had seemed a little too eager to get me into the apartment. Almost like he was trying to convince me it was the perfect place for me, without ever explaining why.
“Sunny and Beans will be happy here,” he had said with a grin, almost too knowing. “You’ll see.”
At the time, I chalked it up to his awkwardness, but now I wondered if there was more to his words than just a well-meaning comment.
I decided to ask my neighbor, a woman named Ruth who lived in the apartment next door. I hadn’t really spoken to her much, but we’d exchanged pleasantries in passing. Maybe she knew something about the building’s history or the landlord.
Ruth was sitting on her porch when I knocked, a cup of tea in her hand. She gave me a warm smile and invited me in. As we chatted, I felt a little guilty, like I was prying, but I couldn’t let go of the strange feeling I had about the whole situation.
“Ruth, do you know anything about the previous tenants?” I asked, trying to keep my tone casual. “I’ve been living here for a little while now, and I noticed something odd.”
Her smile faltered just a little, and she shifted in her seat, clearly uncomfortable. “Well, it’s not my business, dear,” she said, her voice quiet. “But I’ll tell you this: the last tenants… they didn’t stay long. Only about a year. And they moved out in a hurry.”
I raised an eyebrow. “Why’s that?”
She hesitated, as if weighing whether to continue. Finally, she spoke. “There were rumors. About the cats, mostly. You see, the family that lived here before you had two cats, just like yours. Same colors. Same behavior. And they were… very attached to the couch. Specifically, the corner cushion. I heard strange things about it, but… you know how it is. People talk.”
My heart started racing. The same behavior? The same position? The corner cushion? It was too much of a coincidence.
“Do you know where they went after they left?” I asked, leaning forward.
Ruth looked hesitant. “I heard they moved out quickly, without telling anyone. Left in the middle of the night. Never came back. The landlord wasn’t happy about it, though. He didn’t say much, but there was definitely some tension there.”
I felt a cold shiver run down my spine. What had happened in that apartment before I moved in? Why were the cats acting so strangely? And why was there a photo under the couch?
The next day, I couldn’t take it anymore. I decided to do some digging, reaching out to the previous tenants through social media. It took a couple of tries, but eventually, I got a response from a woman named Sarah. She seemed nervous but agreed to meet me for coffee.
When we sat down, I was anxious to hear what she had to say. I couldn’t help but stare at her. She looked almost exactly like me, with the same brown hair and green eyes. And her voice, when she spoke, was laced with an odd familiarity.
“Sarah, I have to ask you about the cats,” I began, my voice trembling. “I’ve been noticing something strange. The cats—Sunny and Beans—they’re acting like the cats you used to have. Same behavior. Same spot on the couch.”
Her face went pale. “You found the photo, didn’t you?” she asked, her voice tight with fear.
I nodded, unable to speak.
She leaned in closer, her hands shaking. “You have to get out of there. You don’t understand what’s going on in that apartment. The cats… they were never ours. They were…” She trailed off, as though the words were too painful to say.
“Tell me,” I urged. “Please.”
“They were part of something. Something that the landlord… he’s not who he says he is. Those cats—they were connected to something much darker. And when we left, we never told anyone what happened. We couldn’t. We were too scared.”
The words hit me like a freight train. I had no idea what she meant, but I knew one thing: I had to leave that apartment.
Just then, a light bulb went off in my head. The karmic twist. The cats had somehow connected the past with the present, bringing me face-to-face with something I never would have discovered otherwise. And now, I had the chance to break the cycle.
That afternoon, I packed up my things and left. I didn’t look back. And as I drove away, I could feel the weight lifting off my shoulders. Sometimes, the universe has a strange way of pushing you to make decisions you never thought you’d have to make. But if you listen carefully, you’ll always find your way out.
